Dhaka University Lacks Access to Top Research Journals
Dhaka University researchers have to rely on colleagues working abroad to obtain articles from leading international research journals because the university lacks access to those publications, Treasurer Professor M Jahangir Alam Chowdhury said on Sunday.
He made the remarks at a seminar titled “Industry-Academia Collaboration: Government Policy and the Position of Dhaka University” at the Nawab Nawab Ali Chowdhury Senate Bhaban auditorium. Dhaka University and Industry-Academia Collaboration jointly organised the seminar to strengthen cooperation between universities and industries.
Professor Chowdhury said inadequate research funding and limited access to academic resources were major obstacles to generating new knowledge and conducting research relevant to industries. Without access to essential journals, universities cannot produce new knowledge or research that meets industrial needs, he said.
Speaking about unemployment, the treasurer said there was a relationship between education levels and unemployment in Bangladesh. Unemployment increases as the level of education rises, he said, adding that the unemployment rate among tertiary-educated people was around 14%.
However, he estimated that the rate could approach 50% if underemployment were included. Although he acknowledged that he did not have specific data to support the estimate, he said the situation could be close to that figure. In this context, he said, there was no alternative to stronger industry-academia collaboration to address unemployment.
Recalling a recent visit to China for a programme, Professor Chowdhury said he had visited one of the world's leading solar panel manufacturers and spoken to its senior executives. He learned that the company had its own research centre and was simultaneously conducting research projects with 12 universities.
He said similar arrangements existed among leading manufacturing companies in different sectors in China. Bangladesh, however, had yet to establish such initiatives. Universities might not have taken the necessary steps, while industries had also failed to show sufficient initiative, he said.
Professor Chowdhury said industry-academia collaboration could create a win-win situation for both universities and industries. Industries provide a platform for applying knowledge developed in classrooms and laboratories, making it possible to assess its practical applications, usability and benefits.
“Collaboration with industries is also necessary to address various challenges facing the state. Such cooperation can bring benefits in areas such as increasing agricultural production, tackling climate change-related problems and expanding solar energy production,” he added.
The treasurer said universities' ability to generate new knowledge and conduct research was essential to making industry-academia collaboration effective. According to the World Intellectual Property Organization's Global Innovation Index, Bangladesh ranked 105th among 139 countries, while India ranked 38th, Sri Lanka 94th and Pakistan 95th.
Comparing the countries' input and output rankings in the index, he said India ranked 49th in input and 25th in output. Sri Lanka ranked 102nd in input and 87th in output, Pakistan 121st and 72nd, respectively, while Bangladesh ranked 115th in input and 92nd in output.
The figures indicated that Bangladesh was generating relatively good output with lower input, he said, although Pakistan was performing better in this regard.
He also said Bangladesh ranked 127th in the Global Innovation Index's second pillar, Human Capital and Research. India ranked 54th, Pakistan 119th and Sri Lanka 117th. In tertiary education, Bangladesh ranked 123rd, compared with India's 88th and Sri Lanka's 94th. Pakistan's position was 127th, although he described the ranking as based on estimates.
Highlighting the low participation of Bangladeshi students in science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM), Professor Chowdhury said only 11% of students in the country's tertiary education system studied STEM subjects. The proportion was 27% in India and 25% in Sri Lanka, while data for Pakistan was unavailable.
He attributed the low interest in science education partly to a lack of employment opportunities. Students knew that the jobs they needed after studying science were not available in the country, he said, which discouraged them from pursuing STEM education.
He added that Bangladesh ranked 126th in knowledge creation, compared with India's 39th and Sri Lanka's 99th. Pakistan's estimated position was 55th. These figures, he said, indicated that Bangladesh still lacked a suitable environment for research and innovation, as well as adequate employment opportunities and the conditions necessary to generate new knowledge.
The treasurer identified inadequate research funding as one of the major reasons behind the situation. He said only 2% of Dhaka University's total budget for the current fiscal year had been allocated to research.
Such a small allocation was insufficient to develop a research environment or build an ecosystem for generating new knowledge, he said. Although the university was expected to serve as the country's knowledge-generation hub and provide leadership in the field, the current allocation made that difficult. Nevertheless, he said, Dhaka University remained the country's leading institution in research and innovation.
Professor Chowdhury said an environment that encouraged free thinking and intellectual freedom was essential for effective industry-academia collaboration. Without such an environment, institutions could not generate new knowledge or produce knowledge that was practical and useful.
He said Dhaka University had yet to establish a Technology Transfer Office, although initiatives had been taken to set one up and he hoped it would become operational soon. He also stressed the need to establish similar offices at all universities across the country.
Calling for greater involvement of industry representatives in university teaching and curriculum development, he said merely preparing a curriculum and seeking feedback from industries would not be enough. Industry representatives should be directly involved in the curriculum development process, with universities working with them to determine what subjects should be taught and how they should be taught to improve students' employment prospects.
He said research was essential to increasing production. Without generating new knowledge and applying it, the manufacturing sector would not achieve its desired growth.
The treasurer also stressed the need to explain the financial benefits of university-industry collaboration to businesses. Securing research funding from industries was difficult, he said. The government could encourage companies to invest in research by offering tax credits for research and development (R&D) and establishing research funds for projects conducted in collaboration with universities.
He further said Bangladesh had yet to develop an effective framework to protect intellectual property generated through research. There was no clear structure determining ownership and the extent of protection for knowledge produced through research funded by universities or industries.
Without a comprehensive framework, he said, industries would be reluctant to collaborate with universities or spend money on research.
Emphasising the need for support systems for university faculty members, Professor Chowdhury said researchers needed regular training and access to international conferences and sources of new knowledge.
He said Dhaka University still lacked access to the world's leading academic journals. Recalling his own experience, he said he had contacted three colleagues working abroad the previous day while trying to obtain a research article on a particular subject.
One of the colleagues downloaded and sent him the article, allowing him to access it, he said. He stressed that a university without access to academic journals and new knowledge could not generate new knowledge or produce research suitable for industry. He also urged the education minister to ensure adequate budgets and allocations for training researchers and teachers.
Professor Chowdhury called for an intermediary support system or network to connect universities and industries. NGOs and private-sector organisations could help identify which universities, laboratories or researchers could address specific industrial problems.
Such organisations could guide industries to the universities best equipped to provide solutions, identify available research facilities and connect businesses with relevant researchers. He said an intermediary layer was needed to establish these connections.
Emphasising coordination among the government, universities and industries, he said effective cooperation among the three parties could help universities generate knowledge needed by industries, provide necessary support to businesses and establish an enabling framework for research.
He described the approach as the “Triple Helix Model of Innovation”.
Concluding his speech, Professor Chowdhury expressed hope that Dhaka University and other universities would develop effective partnerships with industries and establish research structures capable of generating industry-relevant knowledge and supporting businesses.
Education Minister Dr ANM Ehsanul Haque Milon attended the seminar as the chief guest. Dhaka University Vice-Chancellor Professor Dr ABM Obaidul Islam presided over the event.
Pro-Vice-Chancellor (Academic) Professor Dr Abdus Salam, Pro-Vice-Chancellor (Administration) Professor Dr Mohammad Almojadid Alfezani, Treasurer Professor M Jahangir Alam Chowdhury and DU Syndicate member and Marketing Department Professor Dr Md Morshed Hasan Khan attended as special guests.
Professor Dr Abdullah-Al-Mamun, a member of the University Grants Commission of Bangladesh, presented the keynote paper. Professor Dr Md Mohiuddin, president of University and Industry Collaboration and a professor at the Institute of Business Administration (IBA), delivered the welcome address.
Leading representatives from more than 100 industries, deans of various faculties, residential hall provosts, department chairpersons, institute directors, teachers, student representatives, heads of university offices, and presidents and chairpersons of different organisations also attended the seminar.